Previous  Handwriting of our Ancestors  Next

VOLUNTARY AND INVOLUNTARY INFORMATION

Several types of mistakes that resulted when individuals purposefully or unknowingly gave the census writers incorrect information. For example, some Germanic people remembered the compulsory military service requirements of the old country and did not know the laws in America. They often felt that if they divulged their correct names and ages they would be inducted into U.S. military service. To avoid being located, they would often use their middle name(s), delete their first names or surnames, or use only their christening names. Albert Martin Frederick Nass, could thus appear in the records under the following variations:

Albert Nass Frederick Nass
Albert Frederick Martin Frederick
Frederick Martin Albert Martin
Martin Nass  

Since the writers were being paid by the number of names they gathered, they did not always take the data from a member of the household they were visiting. Many writers traveled long distances on foot or by horse, so when they came to an empty dwelling it was common practice to have a neighbor volunteer the information. This practice compounds the errors made on the original census manuscripts, and perpetuated by indexers or researchers. Here is an example of the actual information given by the individuals themselves, and what the neighbor reported:

Thomas James Baldwin M 28-years old born in Ohio
Mary Francis Baldwin F 26-years old born in Ohio
John C. Baldwin M 5-years old born in Kansas
Bella E. Baldwin F 3-years old born in Kansas
Rosella A. Baldwin F 2-years old born in Illinois
Thomas D. Baldwin M 6/12-years old born in Kansas

This is what the neighbor reported:

Thomas Baldwin M 31-years old born in Pennsylvania
Mary Baldwin F 33-years old born in Maryland
J. Baldwin M 9-years old born in Ohio
Bell Baldwin F 7-years old born in Ohio
Rose Baldwin F 3-years old born in Ohio
Thom Baldwin Jun. M 2-years old born in Kansas

As you can see, the information provided by the neighbor was somewhere within the realm of truth, but by no means accurate.